By the Nivelle Trade Desk. Reviewed by the Nivelle New York team.
On loose stones the gap is now very wide: in 2025 a typical 1 ct round lab-grown diamond sold for about 82% less than a natural stone of the same size and shape, and a 2 ct stone for about 89% less, according to analyst Edahn Golan (page dated August 2026). In finished jewelry the gap at retail is narrower (about 71% in the worked example below, which uses assumed numbers), because the gold, the setting labor and the finishing cost the same whichever diamond goes into the mounting. On margin, most stores keep a higher percentage on lab-grown but far fewer gross profit dollars per sale, so the lab-grown case has to sell several times faster to earn what one natural sale earns.
Prices in this category move quickly, so every market figure below carries its date and source. Our position at Nivelle is plain: natural diamonds are the better investment for a store and its customer, and we offer lab-grown in the best interest of our customers and by major request.
The gap on loose stones, dated
The figures below are the most recent published numbers we could find as of November 18, 2026. Treat them as a snapshot, not a forecast.
| Measure | Figure | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 ct round | Lab-grown retailed about 82% below natural in 2025 | Edahn Golan, page dated August 2026 |
| 2 ct round | Lab-grown retailed about 89% below natural in 2025 | Edahn Golan, August 2026 |
| Lab-grown wholesale | 1 ct lab-grown rounds traded at about $80 per carat by mid-2026, down from about $1,800 per carat in 2018 | Edahn Golan, August 2026 |
| Analyst retail gap | Lab-grown retails "90%, 95% less" than an equivalent natural diamond | Paul Zimnisky on Marketplace, July 30, 2026 |
| Natural rough | Down about 20% year over year and roughly half of the early 2022 peak | Zimnisky index, as reported by Marketplace, July 30, 2026 |
The two analysts measure different baskets, so treat 80% to 95% as the range rather than a single figure. Two things follow for a buyer. In most finished pieces the lab-grown stone is now a minor part of the cost, so lab-grown jewelry prices are driven mostly by gold and labor. And natural prices have been falling too, which matters for the replacement value of natural stock already in your case.
Why the gap is narrower in finished jewelry
A tennis bracelet, a pair of studs or a band carries the same 14K gold weight, the same setting time and the same finishing whether the stones are natural or lab-grown. When the stone cost collapses, the mounting cost does not. The further the piece is from a loose stone, the narrower the gap, with the exact ratio depending on how much of the piece is metal and labor; the worked example below, built on assumed numbers, lands the lab-grown ticket at about 29% of the natural ticket. A thin band with small stones shows a smaller gap than a 5 ct tennis bracelet, where the stones are most of the cost of the natural version.
Finished lab-grown jewelry is also where the volume is. Tenoris reported on November 9, 2026 that lab-grown diamond jewelry unit sales rose 22% over the past year, with the growth concentrated in the $1,500 to $5,000 bracket at an average of about $2,000 per item, in a report whose sales figures run through October 2026 (Tenoris).
What margin a jeweler keeps on each
Published figures on margin are thinner than figures on price. Edahn Golan's page (August 2026) puts the typical retail markup on loose lab-grown diamonds, not finished jewelry, at 250% to 300% over cost (a 3.5 to 4 times multiple), and gives an average gross margin of about 73%. Natural diamond jewelry in most independent stores is marked up less in percentage terms, because the cost base is higher and customers compare more carefully at those prices. The pattern most stores report is the same: a higher percentage on lab-grown, far more dollars per sale on natural.
The worked example below uses assumed numbers to show the arithmetic. They are illustrative, not a Nivelle quote and not a market average. Replace them with your own landed cost and your own ticket.
| Line | Natural bracelet, 3 ct total | Lab-grown bracelet, 3 ct total |
|---|---|---|
| Wholesale cost (assumed) | $4,200 | $1,100 |
| Retail ticket (assumed) | $9,450 | $2,750 |
| Retail multiple | 2.25 times | 2.5 times |
| Gross profit | $5,250 | $1,650 |
| Gross margin | 55.6% | 60.0% |
| Retail price gap | Lab-grown ticket is 29.1% of natural, a gap of 70.9% | |
In this example the lab-grown bracelet earns a higher percentage but $3,600 less per sale; the natural bracelet earns 3.18 times the gross profit dollars. If the lab-grown style sells three times in the year the natural style sells once, the lab-grown style earns $4,950 for the year on $3,300 of cost of goods, against $5,250 on $4,200 for the single natural sale, with only $1,100 tied up in the case at any one time instead of $4,200. In short, lab-grown earns its keep through turns, and natural earns it per sale.
What this means for the case
Three practical conclusions follow for the case.
- Price each category on its own schedule. Set the lab-grown ticket from lab-grown cost and competition, not as a fixed discount to the natural piece beside it. Our margins guide for lab-grown jewelry covers the ticketing in detail.
- Watch replacement cost, not just margin. A natural piece bought two years ago may now cost less to replace; a lab-grown piece bought two years ago very likely costs less to replace on the stone side, though gold may have moved the other way. Reorder in smaller quantities and more often where lead times allow.
- Put the gap to work at the counter. Many stores find the clearest pitch is a bigger look for the same spend in lab-grown, and rarity and lasting value for natural, with each piece tagged plainly as one or the other. Natural remains the better investment for the customer who wants a piece that holds its worth; lab-grown suits the customer who wants the look at a lower spend and understands that the stone itself is not an investment.
A Nivelle example: what a lab-grown spec looks like
Nivelle prices lab-grown on its own schedule, separate from natural (see our lab-grown diamond jewelry program), and the standard for lab-grown pieces is E-F color and VS or better clarity. The table below is the live specification of one of our lab-grown tennis bracelet styles at an entry price point, the Nova Bezel Trio round lab-grown diamond tennis bracelet, read from the product page on November 18, 2026. Trade pricing appears after account approval, and the price sheet is synced to the gold market.
| Specification | Nova Bezel Trio bracelet |
|---|---|
| Stones | 27 round lab-grown diamonds |
| Total carat weight | 1.02 ct |
| Color and clarity | F+ color, VS+ clarity |
| Setting | Bezel-set in clusters of three |
| Length and clasp | 7 inch, box clasp with safety catch |
| Metal | 14K yellow, white or rose gold |
The same style can run under your own name through our private label program, and the natural diamond program covers the natural side of the case; matching styles across the two programs are confirmed on the quote.
Frequently asked questions
Lab-grown prices keep falling. How much inventory should a store carry, and how do I avoid being stuck with overpriced stock?
Buy fewer pieces of each style and reorder the ones that sell. Made-to-order lead times of 4 to 6 weeks (Nivelle, confirmed on the quote) let most stores hold one of each proven style rather than a size run of everything. Review the category every quarter against current replacement cost.
How should a jeweler display, tag and price lab-grown and natural diamond jewelry in the same store without cutting into natural gross margin dollars?
Separate cases or clearly separated trays, every tag marked lab-grown or natural, and separate ticketing logic. Most stores that report success keep natural for bridal and milestone purchases and use lab-grown for fashion and gifting price points, so the two categories serve different occasions rather than the same one.
Is it worth buying loose lab-grown stones and contracting the setting separately?
For most stores it is rarely worth it. With 1 ct lab-grown rounds trading at about $80 per carat wholesale by mid-2026 (Edahn Golan, August 2026), the stone is the smaller part of the cost, so the saving from sourcing loose is small, while the risk of mismatched stones, setting delays and uneven finish sits with you. A finished piece from one supplier carries one landed cost, one quality standard and one party responsible when a reorder has to match.
What color and clarity should a retailer expect as standard on wholesale lab-grown diamond jewelry, and is it stated on the invoice?
Standards vary by supplier, so ask. Nivelle's standard on lab-grown pieces is E-F color and VS or better clarity, with IGI or GSI screening on bulk and program orders; how the grade appears on your paperwork is confirmed on the quote.
Work with Nivelle
Nivelle is a New York-managed wholesale and private label supplier of lab-grown and natural diamond jewelry for retailers, brands and designers, a family business since 1978 and now in its third generation. Lab-grown and natural are priced on separate schedules, trade pricing appears after account approval, and a Tax ID and trade references are required. Our trade pricing has proven to be 15-30% below larger supply houses on like-for-like pieces.
Become a retail partner, schedule a 15-minute introduction, or email sales@nivelle.nyc.
Nivelle, New York. A family business since 1978.
Leave a comment